Is the New o1 Model Better than GPT-4o?

It’s December – the world is slowing down, and snow is falling in some corners. However OpenAI? They’re simply getting began. In true festive spirit, Sam Altman and his staff are kicking off a 12-day reward spree, and the primary one is an enormous deal: OpenAI o1 – their most succesful mannequin but. For months, GPT-4 has been the go-to LLM for every little thing, however now, o1 is right here to shake issues up. What does it deliver to the desk? On this weblog, we are going to put OpenAI’s o1 and GPT-4o in opposition to one another for a couple of duties and see which mannequin comes out because the winner. Let’s start.

OpenAI o1- What’s New?

OpenAI’s newest o1 mannequin is a refined model of its o1-preview mannequin which was launched in September 2024. It’s designed to deal with extra advanced duties with better precision and pace.

• When in comparison with its predecessor o1-preview, o1 demonstrates a exceptional means to assume extra concisely for easier issues. Its considering time is proportionate to the issue degree of the question.
• In response to OpenAI, o1 outperforms its predecessor, o1-Preview considerably in mathematical reasoning, and coding-related duties.
• o1 has multimodal capabilities which suggests it could possibly work with textual content, pictures, and audio whereas o1 preview was solely restricted to textual content.

Study Extra: OpenAI o1 is Out: The Most Superior Mannequin is Accessible to USE!

How you can entry o1?

o1 is offered in ChatGPT Plus and ChatGPT Professional plan. It’s not accessible within the free plan. Whereas the ChatGPT Professional plan permits limitless chats with o1, the Plus plan solely permits a restricted variety of chats with o1. To entry o1:

• Head to ChatGPT and login into your Professional/Plus account.
• On the prime, on the left-hand facet of the display screen, beneath the mannequin alternative, you may choose the mannequin that you just want to work with.

o1 vs. GPT-4o: The Showdown

Even with the o1 preview making noise in the previous few months, GPT-4o has held its floor because the best choice for each technical and non-technical customers of ChatGPT. Launched in Could 2024, GPT-4o is a refined multimodal mannequin celebrated for its precision, pace, and flexibility.

It seamlessly processes textual content, pictures, and audio with human-like response occasions and state-of-the-art accuracy. Excelling in advanced reasoning and nuanced understanding, it boasts a formidable 88.7% rating on MMLU benchmarks, setting a excessive commonplace for multimodal AI.

Now o1 is stealing the highlight with its distinctive efficiency in arithmetic, coding, and sophisticated problem-solving. It’s a daring declare to the highest, however does o1 really outperform GPT-4o as the last word mannequin?

To search out out, we’re placing each to the check with 5 difficult duties. Listed here are the 5 duties:

1. Understanding the issue and designing a move chart
2. Picture evaluation with science
3. Picture evaluation with arithmetic
4. Clear up a Sudoku puzzle
5. Picture technology

Let’s see which LLM emerges because the undisputed champion!

Problem 1: Perceive the Downside and Design a Stream Chart

Immediate: “I would like a easy move diagram and an in depth rationalization of the instruments and applied sciences required to implement a sentiment evaluation system.

The system ought to fetch stock-related information utilizing a Information API, analyze the sentiment (optimistic, unfavourable, or impartial), and ship a 140-character abstract and the sentiment to clients.”

Consequence:

With GPT-4o we bought a conceptual description of the move diagram together with a obscure picture representing a move diagram. Although the textual content description showcases the steps exactly and precisely, the diagram is filled with spelling errors and a complicated move of occasions.

With o1 we bought a easy but clear flowchart with no spelling errors. Then within the textual content description, we bought the small print relating to every a part of the flowchart – defined nicely. We bought some further info on different instruments and applied sciences we may use for the duty. Lastly, we bought a concise abstract explaining every step in short – a whole end-to-end reply!

Verdict: For this job – o1 struck the ball proper out of the park.

Problem 2: Picture Evaluation with Science

Immediate: “Calculate the output of this circuit diagram.”

(reference)

Consequence:

GPT-4o identifies the circuit diagram appropriately and it appropriately identifies some elements of the picture together with the enter and output voltage. Nonetheless, it fails to learn the graph throughout the picture to realize insights into the voltage values. Reasonably, in its response, it prompts us for these values for additional calculation.

o1, takes a few seconds to research the picture. It appropriately identifies all of the elements and in addition reads the values for every part from the picture. The mannequin describes the operation carried out throughout the circuit. It then calculates the important thing parameters of the circuit, takes into consideration even the small load components, and studies it. A grasp stroke by o1! Not solely did it perceive the duty, nevertheless it additionally learn all of the values from the graphs throughout the picture to calculate the output values- appropriate & concise!

Verdict: Clearly, o1 is a grasp at Physics!

Problem 3: Picture Evaluation with Arithmetic

Immediate: “What’s the win likelihood for every staff on this recreation?”

Consequence:

Generated by GPT-4o

Generated by o1

GPT-4o did perceive the sport appropriately nevertheless it couldn’t appropriately perceive the format that was being performed. It did learn different particulars within the picture appropriately just like the rating and the wickets taken by the bowler. But general its evaluation wasn’t detailed and it didn’t give us the win likelihood for any staff.

o1, understood the duty, and it did an incredible job analyzing the picture. From appropriately figuring out the sport, and the format in addition to particulars relating to the staff that’s fielding and relating to the tea break as nicely. Lastly, it does a incredible job calculating the win likelihood for every staff giving nice causes to assist its reply.

Verdict: o1 does the job and does it nicely!

Problem 4: Clear up a Sudoku Puzzle

Immediate: “Clear up the next Sudoku and provides the ultimate answer as a picture.”

Consequence:

Generated by o1

GPT-4o generates the reply as a Matplotlib chart immediately. The response was fast but incorrect.

o1 however takes a while to consider the answer. It rigorously places dots within the locations of blanks after which it tries a number of iterations, explains the placements, then it additionally identifies the error in every of its options however ultimately, the ultimate end result it generates, nonetheless isn’t the correct answer. Its response was delayed, nicely thought out, but incorrect!

Verdict: So for this job, each GPT-4o and o1 failed to provide the correct answer, which was:

Problem 5: Picture Era

Immediate: “Create a picture of a canine operating near the seashore”

Consequence:

GPT-4o is fast to generate the picture of a cheerful canine leaping across the seashore. Doing the duty as we requested shortly and effectively. Oh and what a cute canine!

o1 for now can not generate pictures. Therefore, it simply supplies us with an in depth immediate that we will use to generate a picture utilizing an AI picture generator. Not linked with DALL.E but it appears!

Verdict: For this problem, GPT-4o stands unbeaten.

Conclusion

o1 is undoubtedly outshining GPT-4o in most cases. With its improved reasoning and logical considering capabilities, it excels at understanding advanced queries and producing extra related, exact responses. It’s sooner than the o1 preview model and notably extra concise in its solutions.

However is it good? Is it AGI? Definitely not. Like several mannequin, o1 has its limitations. It could generate incorrect responses and should require a number of iterations to reach on the desired final result.

That mentioned, o1 is a exceptional device for researchers, scientists, designers, and even college students. Its distinctive problem-solving expertise, eager consideration to element, and superior voice options make it a robust useful resource. Whether or not it’s tackling advanced duties or helping with artistic workflows, o1 holds immense potential to boost productiveness and innovation.

Continuously Requested Questions