Adobe Firefly 3 vs Firefly 2: Is Newer Always Better

Between Midjourney, DALL-E, Meta, and Steady Diffusion — the race for the perfect AI picture generator is already too near name. Nevertheless it’s about to get even tighter. Adobe simply launched Adobe Firefly 3, and we’re right here to provide it a attempt.

However right here’s the query in everybody’s thoughts: is newer all the time higher? 

On this article, I’ll be evaluating Adobe Firefly 3 with Adobe Firefly 2. We’ll deal with its options, nuance, and output high quality. Keep tuned!

What’s Adobe Firefly?

Adobe Firefly is Adobe’s official AI picture generator mannequin. It’s created to generate business photos and seamlessly join with different merchandise from the Adobe suite like Photoshop, InDesign, Premiere, Illustrator and extra. As of Might 2024, its newest mannequin is the Adobe Firefly 3, which we’ll assessment right this moment compared to its earlier iteration.

Adobe Firefly 2 vs. Adobe Firefly 3: Options

With Adobe Firefly 3, you’ll nonetheless get your favourite Adobe Firefly 2 options like side ratio management, switching between photos or artwork, customization options comparable to visible depth and elegance power, and extra.

Nonetheless, this third iteration introduces 4 new options that may actually get previous and new customers excited. These are the next:

• Higher Nuance and Creativity: This one’s a given, however Adobe Firefly guarantees to grasp prompts higher and generate extra stunning photos with this new replace.
• Generative Broaden: Means that you can enter a picture and Adobe Firefly will increase its side ratio by analyzing the picture and filling in the remainder of the canvas contextually.
• Model Reference: Much like Midjourney’s fashion reference characteristic, Adobe Firefly will now allow you to use a third-party picture as a reference information for the ultimate appear and feel of the output.
• Construction Reference: Enables you to use a picture as a structural template of the generated picture.

Adobe Firefly 2 vs. Adobe Firefly 3: Output Comparability

Realism (Portrait)

Immediate: a lady after a marathon, medium shot, autumn backdrop

Surprisingly, I barely choose Adobe Firefly 2’s output right here if we’re going purely by realism. It’s well-framed, shot physics are on level, extra candid, and the “autumn backdrop” is extra refined. The one situation I’ve is that it truly didn’t comply with an necessary a part of the immediate, which is “after marathon.” The girl continues to be in motion within the picture.

Then again, I see no points within the Adobe Firefly 3’s output. What’s necessary is that it adopted the immediate higher, which is why I’m reluctantly giving this win to Firefly 3.

Industrial Images

Immediate: product pictures, craft beer, stunning lighting, classic aesthetics, ultra-detailed

This spherical goes to Adobe Firefly 3, no query. The earlier iteration’s picture simply seems to be too faux, particularly the rendering of the beer. It’s too clean, with none fizz besides from the build-up on the high. Then again, Firefly 3’s output may legitimately cross as actual product pictures.

Digital Artwork

Immediate: minimal summary illustration, two fireflies with completely different designs in an exquisite forest, neon colours, nightfall, watercolor

This can be a matter of non-public desire, however I truly like Adobe Firefly 2’s design higher than its newer counterpart. It feels extra private, handmade, and even slightly kitsch. Don’t get me incorrect — Adobe Firefly 3’s output is much more intricate, however there’s simply one thing in regards to the former iteration’s high quality that makes me adore it extra.

Character Design

Immediate: comedian guide illustration, a person who can management ice, character design

That is 100% an enchancment. Though I don’t assume both of those are on par with Midjourney or DALL-E but, this enchancment is certainly a step in the suitable course. Adobe Firefly 3’s output truly seems to be like a comic book guide illustration, whereas Adobe Firefly 2 seems like a poorly-rendered youngsters’s guide illustration.

Structure

Immediate: a japanese-style residence, koi pond, biophilic design, quiet 5pm afternoon

I’m not an enormous fan of both of those designs. They each look okay from afar, however if you zoom in, you may truly see that neither homes are structurally sound. There are numerous rendering points, significantly within the roof and the reflections on the water. This spherical is sadly a tie, however as a result of they’re simply each underwhelming.

With Textual content Technology

Immediate: a highway signal that claims “SLOW DOWN”

Add Adobe Firefly to the checklist of AI picture turbines that may now do textual content. I used to be anticipating a slight enchancment on textual content era, however this was a pleasant shock. Each letter is rendered correctly and it correctly takes under consideration the whitespace between “SLOW” and “DOWN.”

Excessive Context

Immediate: In an enormous, forgotten library chamber bathed in bioluminescent flora, a cloaked determine in an emerald gown with astronomy symbols examines an enormous tome with swirling galaxies on its cowl. Unusual artifacts like a celestial sphere and an astrolabe lie on the lectern because the determine, their face obscured by a hood, turns a web page with a glowing amethyst ring, revealing hints of forgotten data etched on the ground and wisps of power emanating from the tome.

Certainly one of Adobe Firefly 3’s details of enchancment was alleged to be nuance. Nonetheless, based mostly on this output alone, I’m unsure in the event that they’re capable of meet that promise.

Let’s break the immediate down into a number of elements. There ought to be a library, bioluminescent vegetation, a cloaked determine in emerald gown, a tome, swirling galaxies above the determine, unusual artifacts, an amethyst ring on the topic’s finger, and power emanating from the tome.

Adobe Firefly 3 missed numerous these. Then again, Adobe Firefly 2 solely missed one: the amethyst ring. As a lot as I wish to say that the newer model’s immediate understanding is healthier, this one is undoubtedly a win for Adobe Firefly 2.

The Backside Line

Adobe Firefly 3 is certainly an enchancment on its earlier era. Do I really feel prefer it’s an enormous enchancment? Nicely, that’s a special query fully.

There are lots of instances on this comparability that I discovered myself questioning if I like Adobe Firefly 2 or Adobe Firefly 3’s output higher. Whereas that’s okay to occur a few times, the truth that it occurred in nearly all examples is worrying. What’s extra regarding is that Adobe Firefly 2 additionally appears to have higher nuance than Adobe Firefly 3.

However, for what it’s value, that is simply Adobe Firefly 3’s beta model. Who is aware of what enhancements they’ll make as soon as they launch the ultimate model? For now, this comparability was too shut for consolation. 

Need to see extra Adobe Firefly comparisons? Learn extra about this AI picture generator right here and right here.